Skip to main content

Behavioral Interview Tips & Best Practices

Pre-Interview Preparation​

1. Build Your Story Bank​

Create a collection of 6-8 compelling examples that showcase different competencies:

Recommended Story Distribution:

  • 2-3 Leadership/Ownership stories: Leading projects, driving initiatives, taking charge
  • 2-3 Problem-solving/Innovation stories: Overcoming challenges, creative solutions, process improvements
  • 2-3 Collaboration/Teamwork stories: Working with others, cross-functional projects, difficult relationships
  • 1-2 Failure/Learning stories: Mistakes made, lessons learned, growth demonstrated

2. Story Selection Criteria​

Choose stories that are:

  • Recent: Within the last 2-3 years (shows current capabilities)
  • Relevant: Align with the role and company you're interviewing for
  • Impactful: Have measurable business outcomes
  • Personal: Highlight your specific contributions
  • Varied: Cover different situations, teams, and challenges

3. Research-Driven Preparation​

  • Company values: Align your stories with their stated principles
  • Role requirements: Emphasize experiences relevant to the job description
  • Team challenges: Research common challenges the team faces
  • Industry context: Understand market pressures and opportunities

During the Interview​

1. Structure Your Responses with STAR​

Always follow the STAR method, but adapt the emphasis based on the question:

For Leadership Questions: Emphasize Action and Result For Problem-Solving Questions: Focus on Situation complexity and Action creativity For Learning Questions: Highlight Task challenges and Result growth

2. Timing and Pacing​

  • Aim for 2-3 minutes per story: Detailed enough to be compelling, concise enough to stay engaging
  • Watch for cues: If interviewer looks impatient, wrap up the current point
  • Allow for follow-ups: Leave room for deeper questions rather than covering every detail

3. Engage the Interviewer​

  • Make eye contact: Build connection and read reactions
  • Use their name: Personalize your responses
  • Ask clarifying questions: "Would you like me to focus on the technical or leadership aspects?"
  • Check understanding: "Does that answer your question, or would you like me to elaborate on any part?"

4. Handle Difficult Questions​

When You Don't Have a Perfect Example​

"I don't have a direct example of that exact situation, but I can share a similar experience where I faced [related challenge]. In that case..."

When Asked About Failures​

"I appreciate that question because it shows you value growth and learning. Let me share a situation where I made a significant mistake..."

When Asked About Conflicts​

"Conflict is inevitable in collaborative environments, and I've learned to see it as an opportunity for better outcomes. Here's an example..."

Advanced Techniques​

1. The Callback Method​

Reference earlier stories to show patterns and consistency:

"This connects to the project management example I shared earlier. In this situation, I applied similar stakeholder communication principles..."

2. The Bridge Technique​

Connect your answer to the role you're interviewing for:

"This experience taught me the importance of cross-functional collaboration, which I understand is crucial for this role given the matrix structure of your engineering organization."

3. The Growth Arc​

Show progression and learning across multiple examples:

"Early in my career, I would have handled this differently. But after the experience I just shared, I now approach similar situations by..."

4. The Future Application​

Connect past experiences to future opportunities:

"Based on what I learned from this project, I'm excited about the opportunity to apply these lessons to [specific challenge mentioned in job description]."

Common Pitfalls to Avoid​

1. The Rambling Response​

Problem: Losing focus and going off on tangents Solution: Practice with a timer; stick to STAR structure

2. The Vague Answer​

Problem: Generic responses that could apply to anyone Solution: Include specific details, numbers, and personal actions

3. The Team Credit​

Problem: Using "we" instead of "I" throughout the story Solution: Acknowledge team contributions while highlighting your specific role

4. The Perfect Hero​

Problem: Only sharing flawless success stories Solution: Include challenges, setbacks, and learning experiences

5. The Technical Deep Dive​

Problem: Getting lost in technical details Solution: Balance technical content with business impact and leadership lessons

Body Language and Presentation​

1. Confident Posture​

  • Sit up straight with shoulders back
  • Lean slightly forward to show engagement
  • Keep hands visible and use natural gestures

2. Eye Contact​

  • Maintain natural eye contact (not staring)
  • Look at all interviewers if it's a panel
  • Use eye contact to emphasize key points

3. Voice and Tone​

  • Speak clearly and at moderate pace
  • Vary your tone to maintain interest
  • Show enthusiasm for your accomplishments

4. Energy Management​

  • Start with high energy for first impressions
  • Maintain consistent engagement throughout
  • Show genuine excitement about the opportunity

Question Flow Management​

1. Opening Strong​

Lead with your strongest, most relevant story early in the interview to set a positive tone.

2. Reading the Room​

  • If interviewer seems technical: Include more technical details
  • If interviewer seems business-focused: Emphasize business impact
  • If interviewer seems people-focused: Highlight team dynamics and relationships

3. Closing Strong​

End with a story that shows growth, learning, and future potential.

4. Asking Great Questions​

Turn the tables with thoughtful questions:

  • "What does success look like in this role after the first 90 days?"
  • "What are the biggest challenges the team is facing right now?"
  • "How do you see this role evolving over the next year?"

Post-Interview Best Practices​

1. Immediate Follow-up​

  • Send thank you email within 24 hours
  • Reference specific conversation points
  • Reiterate your interest and qualifications

2. Self-Reflection​

  • Note questions you struggled with
  • Identify stories that resonated well
  • Plan improvements for future interviews

3. Continued Interest​

  • Share relevant articles or insights
  • Connect on LinkedIn with personalized message
  • Follow up appropriately based on their timeline

Emergency Strategies​

When Your Mind Goes Blank​

  1. Buy time: "That's a great question, let me think of the best example..."
  2. Start with the situation: Begin with context while your brain catches up
  3. Ask for clarification: "Are you looking for an example of technical leadership or people leadership?"

When You Realize You're Off-Track​

  1. Acknowledge and redirect: "Let me refocus on the specific question you asked..."
  2. Summarize key point: "The main takeaway from this experience was..."
  3. Ask if you should elaborate: "Would you like me to dive deeper into any particular aspect?"

When You Don't Have a Good Example​

  1. Be honest: "I don't have a direct example of that situation..."
  2. Offer related experience: "But I can share a similar situation where..."
  3. Show learning intent: "It's actually something I'd be excited to experience in this role..."

Interview Success Metrics​

Rate yourself after each interview:

Story Quality (1-10)

  • Were examples specific and detailed?
  • Did you show clear personal impact?
  • Were results quantified where possible?

Delivery (1-10)

  • Did you follow STAR structure?
  • Was timing appropriate (2-3 minutes)?
  • Did you maintain energy and engagement?

Relevance (1-10)

  • Did stories align with role requirements?
  • Did you demonstrate company culture fit?
  • Were examples recent and significant?

Connection (1-10)

  • Did you build rapport with interviewer(s)?
  • Did you ask thoughtful questions?
  • Did you show genuine interest and enthusiasm?

Quick Reference Checklist​

✅ Day Before Interview

  • Review your story bank and practice key examples
  • Research interviewer backgrounds on LinkedIn
  • Prepare 3-5 thoughtful questions to ask
  • Get good sleep and plan your timing

✅ Day of Interview

  • Arrive 10-15 minutes early
  • Bring copies of resume and notepad
  • Turn off phone notifications
  • Take deep breaths and project confidence

✅ During Interview

  • Use STAR method for all behavioral questions
  • Include specific details and quantified results
  • Ask clarifying questions when needed
  • Take notes and show active listening

✅ After Interview

  • Send thank you email within 24 hours
  • Note lessons learned for next time
  • Follow up appropriately based on timeline
  • Continue researching the company and role

Remember: The goal isn't perfection—it's authentic connection and demonstration of your capabilities through compelling, well-structured stories.